| Wingate & Finchley | Hastings |
|---|
| 1-0 Alex Solomon A. Solomon 1H | 18ʼ | |
| 2-0 Ruben Carvalho R. Carvalho | 45ʼ+2 | |
| 45ʼ+8 | 2-1 Tommie Fagg T. Fagg | |
| 61ʼ 2H | 2-2 Davide Rodari D. Rodari | |
| 74ʼ | Freddie Legg F. Legg |
 |
E. Long | 22 |
|
R. Carvalho | 21 |
|
A. Chukwu | 17 |
|
D. Goather-Braithwaite | 7 |
|
A. Biler | 2 |
|
D. Rodari | 27 |
|
T. Fagg | 6 |
|
J. Dixon | 4 |
|
I. Oyebola | 3 |
|
K. Moynes | 3 |
| Tirsdag 30. april 2024 | |
|---|---|
| 20:45 | Macclesfield - Worksop |
| 20:45 | Marine - Warrington Rylands |
| Onsdag 1. maj 2024 | |
| 20:45 | AFC Totton - Bracknell Town |
| 20:45 | Chatham Town - Horsham |
| 20:45 | Enfield Town - Wingate & Finchley |
| 20:45 | Leamington - Redditch United |
| 20:45 | Salisbury - Gosport Borough |
| 20:45 | Telford - Mickleover Sports |
